

OSM doesn’t require you to open derivative works, though - they just require attribution. Kind of a different situation.


OSM doesn’t require you to open derivative works, though - they just require attribution. Kind of a different situation.


I know what copyleft licenses are about, that was covered in the post - if you read it. If you are saying that you are making long comments without reading the post, great I guess, but not super interesting (to me).
I’m not really interested in getting into an argument around license choice because I wasn’t advocating for any particular license (like you seem to be).


I said I was focusing on copyleft, cool that you ignored the entire post though. 😑


Yes, exactly.


Closed source Chromium sounds like fun.


Ooops, I posted a reply to someone earlier and got it right (and forgot this one). Thanks for the heads up (fixed now)!


Interestingly, I just interviewed the Waterfox developer, who actually references Oblivious HTTP and his interest in developing this into a paid feature for Waterfox.


I added a section to my post with some additional comment.
I began thinking of privacy because Mozilla was clearly thinking of it when designing this feature, but I don’t think they really thought it through.
People’s browsers are visiting pages that they never intended to. If a random extension did that, you would say that it was violating your privacy. The browser does it, and you get people defending it as “optional”. Yes, but the user never installed the malware extension that is leaking your privacy. It is your browser doing it in an automated update.
If you don’t think this is a privacy issue, why doesn’t the next version of Firefox just visit every page on every page that I visit, so that when I hover over a link, I can get a link preview immediately, without needing to wait. That would save me some real time and effort!


As opposed to the case where you don’t have a link preview, and you click on a website to see what it contains, and they get your IP. The author seems to think Mozilla should have protected our privacy by having someone act as the proxy for the request. Because involving a thirds party that receives all these requests and does work for us for free is absolutely how we protect our privacy.
But that is exactly what Mozilla is telling us – trust us.
Why was the feature added if my browser is going to browse to the page anyway? What is the value add? I was looking for some way for it to make sense - ah right, it could be a privacy preserving feature - I can preview the link and verify whether I want to visit it before I actually visit it. But that isn’t how it works.
Yes, a feature clearly designed for pushing onto that juicy “people with mobility impairments” userbase.
Love that you ignore all of the people who are currently seeing the popups and not understanding why.


It transforms the contribution to no longer be “share alike”.
That doesn’t really discount the argument. Not a lot of investment for a decent return. Why is that bad?


And then later I learned it was a cooperative effort, just not under the same name
Source?


They developed the “privacy sandbox” together.
Yeah that’s not true.


deleted by creator


“Vivaldi is closed source, therefore it’s harder for users to investigate”, which is clearly an inaccurate statement.
Why is it an inaccurate statement?
What user are you thinking of?


You really felt misled that it was harder to inspect? What makes you think I have the expertise to inspect this? I’m not even a user and I wouldn’t know where to start to find the ad blocker within that tarball. Would you?
In any case, I clarified why it was harder to inspect - to me it felt obvious that being closed source made it harder to investigate. The fact that it is also shared source really has no bearing to the general observation, especially since we’re talking about a 2GB tarball where I don’t even know where to start. And I’m a pretty technical person.
How would a user easily investigate this vs. an open source browser?


It is, it is just source available. Still closed source.


I’m asking you what the misinformation is. Is this harder to investigate because the software is closed source? In my mind undoubtedly yes. I know it was harder for ME to investigate because it wasn’t open source - no open issue trackers, SCM repository, whatever.
So please tell me why what I said was misinformation - I’m really curious.


But it is, because making users download a 2GB repo and looking through the code, or crafting custom filter rules to investigate how rules work is harder than looking at a hosted source code repository (like what Brave has).
Where is the misinformation?
They did, but that was for contributions. They still sold access to the encyclopedia to big tech so they could train on it to create slop (in violation of the licenses that Wikipedia is licensed under).