unknownuserunknownlocation

  • 0 Posts
  • 12 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: August 1st, 2025

help-circle


  • This is an age old discussion. The FSF doesn’t “approve” of Debian because it contains proprietary drivers (which are already in the Linux kernel). Even when Debian didn’t have these drivers by default and you had to go out of your way to download an unofficial version that did have these drivers, that was too much for the FSF. Thing is, in most cases you need those drivers to get your hardware working properly. For instance (and IIRC), the latest WiFi version that has a WiFi card available where the drivers are fully open source is WiFi 4 (back then WiFi N).

    There will always be a compromise (setting aside the ID thing on Discord, which is a whole other can of worms and affects open source software as well). Even if you’re running only Linux (or FreeBSD or whatever other open source OS), there are in all likelihood still closed source drivers being used. Or, you decide to limit yourself to WiFi 4 or ethernet connections, for instance. OK, now you don’t have any closed source drivers anymore, yay! Except… The processor and processor architecture your computer is running on isn’t open source. Shit. And in fact, there currently is only one open source processor architecture: RISC-V, but that still has a bit of a ways to go until it’s ready for mass adoption. And even then, I’m sure you’d find something closed source in whatever computer you’d be using. It’s always (at least in the current day and age) a question of how much you can realistically have open source.

    The situation with that game definitely seems a little more extreme in the other direction, unfortunately. The question that I’m wondering is: the game is open source, what’s preventing you from compiling it yourself? That way you don’t have to run it through steam. And if there aren’t proper instructions, check the license of the original project, it may just be a violation of that license (since a clear compilation path is practically a part of the source code, since without you can’t compile it and thus use it properly otherwise).








  • I watched the first 10-15 minutes of this and have to say, while I agree with him on principle, he’s either misinformed or exaggerating the anti-circumvention regulation. There are a number of exemptions in anti-circumvention laws in the US for personal use. How far this goes was made clear in court, Apple took the creators of an iOS jailbreak to court and lost, making it clear that jailbreaking is not illegal, even though it clearly circumvents the “protection” system in place. Similar applies to circumventing DRM for backup copies of media, for instance.

    Of course, I would rather see no anti-circumvention legislation whatsoever, but the way he misportrays the situation makes me question his credibility.