

If you have such requirements like “cannot contain ads, telemetry or freemium features”, then its no longer Open Source. What you want is a custom license with the terms you define like that.


If you have such requirements like “cannot contain ads, telemetry or freemium features”, then its no longer Open Source. What you want is a custom license with the terms you define like that.


More info at https://github.com/bsgcl/SmartTubeLocal/blob/master/FAQ.md . One thing to note is, that this is developed and maintained by a single person. And according to the README https://github.com/bsgcl/SmartTubeLocal:
This repository is maintained offline for private use, but I push updates here as a backup, and for your entertainment.
its a personal project without community involvement.
Also every sentence in the README is its own paragraph. I don’t now why this abomination of style is done. Wish this modern style of writing documents would stop.
To that end, I’m publishing the current 32.71 source code and final release, with the source code frozen at this version.
Download the APKs from the SmartTube LOCAL GitHub Releases page.
I’ll continue to publish updated APKs as I hatch them.
So only the initial release is Open Source. Any further development is closed source. I would recommend to use a different application instead. Otherwise you cannot update if you don’t want to use a proprietary tool in the future. Not really Open Source in my opinion and probably vibe coded and vibe maintained too.


I would love page screenshot though, not just what is visible but the whole rendered page as one, in a PNG.
Firefox can already do that. Right mouse click on the page, select “Take Screenshot” and then choose “Save Full Page”. I actually did a meta screenshot, of the screenshot tool:



I view this comparable to an ad-blocker extension in the browser. It doesn’t block all ads, but it does a decent job that the result is usable. Maybe that is the effect, maybe less. As long as they do not heuristic decision and only go about known stuff, then I’m all for it. My first thought was “oh they fight ai with ai”, but that is not the case as it seems. But it depends on the sources for that filter. If they use Ai to detect, then I’m not a big fan of the filter.


I see. Well that makes sense and is indeed useful then.


Oh man sorry to hear your place got flooded. That sucks, but good on you for not stop trying. Man also, you can’t just do a passwordless login when dealing with the internet. :D And the story with misconfiguring the port is exactly one of the things I’m scared.
NextCloud is also on my todo list,… but I’m too lazy.


Be careful; one project turns into two, which turns into 3
Actually two turns into four! Otherwise I agree with your reply. :-) My next step for searXNG would be to set it up on a low powered device to access from public (for myself only), and use a VPN on it with rotating IPs. To accessing it outside my home. But I’m not ready for that yet. I’m also kind of scared to get hacked someday.


AI slop blocker
How does this work? I mean how decides it is Ai slop or not?


Agreed, hosting is probably the most private web search we have. Only your IP address is still sent to the actual search engines searXNG calls. Using a VPN would solve this last bit too.
An extreme alternative would also be Tor.


Can you prove that there is a backdoor?
I didn’t say there is, I only ask for proofing your point. Remember: Not able to find anything is not the proof of absence. You can only proof something you can find. All I am saying is, if even Linux Kernel ALMOST got hid by a backdoor that was extremely sophisticated, it could happen to Ghidra as well. I’m not saying Ghidra is unsecure or anything like that.
if China, Russia, NK or any other nation state could find a backdoor
Then they would most likely use it to their advantage without telling anyone. Shaming a nation is not as lucrative like abusing a backdoor.


Ghidra is used by the best and brightest malware inspectors.
Can you prove your claim?
If it was backdoored, it would have been discovered almost immediately.
That’s the hope. Reality is, these things still happen. Remember that even the extremely secure Linux Kernel was almost, if it was not discovered accidentally and looked into it, hit bey huge backdoor. What makes you so sure that Ghidra developers and inspectors is on the same level?


I wasn’t talking about GIMP. Photocraft is an exact copy of a program, that was designed and created for decades. My argument is, that Photocraft couldn’t be created in a few weeks if it was from scratch like GIMP or Photoshop was.


Based on a program that is made in decades.


I don’t think that Photocraft is superior. But the reason why its made so quickly is, because its vibe coded. There is no real engineering behind it, no good code quality and its not even a unique project; just stolen another project. And right now it’s even buggy as hell and unfinished mess with missing features too. Besides possible future licensing issues, I wouldn’t even use that program if it was good.
I prefer GIMP over Photoshop or what this abomination of Photocraft is.
The full context of the paragraph, which is important here:
A virtual machine boots a guest operating system. Raven instead implements Windows interfaces through these guest components and supervisor services. Wine also implements Windows interfaces; the distinction here is how Raven divides that work and supervises the guest, rather than whether system libraries exist inside the application’s process.
I’m not entirely understanding this, but it sounds like a hybrid concept between WINE and a virtual machine. So its only partially virtualized.


We should want copyright to be weakened, not strengthened
I’m not sure if this is a good idea.


I’m not saying its impossible, and there is some likelihood of that happening. If this comes true and Microsoft finds about it, then expect them to close the doors soon. In their README they say its clean room implementation, and my reply with clean room + ai is always “if you cannot proof the tools aren’t trained on code you try to implement, then you cannot proof it is clean room”. So I’m right there with your concerns. The only objection I had was that using Ai isn’t proof of having stolen code in the produces output. Otherwise I’m 100% with you.


Objectively speaking this contains internal leaked Microsoft code
Objectively speaking, usage of Ai does not mean that the resulting code does contain internal leaked Microsoft code. It just mean there is potential and without comparing to the original source, we are not able to confirm. Overall the LberNT might or might not contain leaked code, but we are just unable to make definitive statements yet. Unless I am missing something obvious.
Open Source license is also a copyright.