• 0 Posts
  • 33 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: March 23rd, 2025

help-circle
  • Lemmy fetches everything that has ever been posted in any community that any user on that instance is subscribed to and keeps it indefinitely.

    Since most activity happens in big communities that most people are subscribed to, most instances keep full, persistent copies of most things that were ever posted to lemmy.

    That’s why Lemmy scales so badly. If Lemmy was the size of Reddit, every instance would have to have storage capacity in the same order of magnitude as all of Reddit itself.

    The problem only gets worse with time, since all that has been posted still remains.

    The total replication also means that the copies need to be moderated by every instance individually, since every instance stores a copy of everything. So if e.g. someone posts illegal content on another instance and your instance stores a replica, you are just as legally liable for that illegal content as the original instance. Thus you have to moderate everything that runs over your instance.

    Moderation effort is thus also replicated across all instances.

    That bad scaling in storage and moderation is btw the reason why e.g. lemm.ee shut down. It was just too much cost and work to keep the instance running.



  • What’s your point? “Don’t use Linux unless you are a professional user”?

    Beginners have to begin somewhere and they need to get info from somewhere.

    A lot of Linux UX is still at the level where it doesn’t give enough relevant information to a non-technical user in a way that the user can actually make an informed decision. That is the core problem.

    Whether users get their wrong information from AI, Stackoverflow, random tutorials, Google, a friend or somewhere else hardly matters.

    Take for example a look at the setup process of a Synology NAS. A 10yo can successfully navigate that process, because it’s so well done. We need more of that, especially for FOSS stuff.

    Too much of Linux is built by engineers for engineers.


  • I totally agree with the rant, and a big issue is that the Linux community specifically consists to a large part of technicians and not users who then go full *surprised pikachu face* when they see a user who is not a technician.

    But seriosly, how would a (to quote OP) “total beginner” know that AI is not a good place to look for help?

    And, tbh, it sometimes does actually help. AI lies more often than it doesn’t, but it at least tries to help, which is more than I can say of most members of the Linux community.

    I had an issue on Fedora 42 where the performance of my games would randomly be abysmal. One day I can play current AAA titles without issue on my Nvidia 4070, the next day I have to measure performance in “Seconds per Frame” even on 15yo indie titles. This issue only affects game started from Heroic, all other things I try including all debugging stuff works fine.

    I’m not a new Linux user. I’m a developer and I’ve been using Linux for about 20 years. So I get to debugging, googling, reading bug reports, all that, and can’t find anything. I ask on StackExchange, Lemmy, even Reddit, no result. Most people are like “Works on my machine, noob”, and a handful people are like "I have the same issue and no solution.

    So after a year or so I swallow my pride and ask ChatGPT. The first answer is correct: Heroic (and thus all proton/wine games it spawns) runs in Flatpak. Flatpak has its own version of the Nvidia drivers, and if that version doesn’t exactly match the OS driver version it falls back to software rendering. So if I do dnf update and it updates the Nvidia drivers this breaks my performance until I do flatpak update. I often ran flatpak update before dnf update and thus my performance sucked.

    Yes, the majority of the answers I get from AI are lies. But without AI I would still not be able to game on my system.

    AI is a tool, and for beginners its a tricky tool, because sometimes it works perfectly, but sometimes it totally messes everything up. The same holds true for pretty much any other source of information made for beginners. Before “Don’t paste AI commands into CLI” we had “Don’t paste stuff from Stackoverflow into CLI” and before that it was “Don’t paste stuff you found on Google into CLI”.



  • The only evidence that OP irreparably nuked their hardware is ChatGPTs word.

    The bigger issue ad hand is that everyone here is a noob when it comes to exotic hardware like SAS, and still everyone here thinks they are 1337 haxors enough to tell OP that they are a noob idiot.

    Tbh, if OP asks for help here and there’s 49 comments of people being dicks and one that actually helps it might be worthwhile. But as it stands it’s 50 to 0, with nobody here beeing educated enough to know anything about the subject.



  • I had a problem with Fedora 42, where the performance of my games would be fine one day and abysmal another day. Couldn’t find a pattern. I googled a ton, tried to debug myself, asked on reddit, stackexchange, the fedora forum and lemmy. I only got answers like “Works fine on my machine, noob” and “I have that problem too”. It only affected games running in proton on heroic, everything else was fine.

    After about a year of on-and-off debugging and asking around, I swallowed my pride and asked ChatGPT.

    First answer from that thing was correct: I had run dnf update without doing a flatpak update right afterwards. Turns out, flatpak has its own copy of Nvidia drivers and if the system driver is updated without the flatpak copy being updated, it falls back to software rendering. So the performance was crap until I did flatpak update the next time, and broke again when I ran dnf update.

    I still haven’t found that in any documentation so far.

    AI is crap more often than not, but it does at least try to help and sometimes it actually does.

    Look in this thread here. Is there even a single answer that tries to help OP, or is every single answer here just dumb snark?


  • squaresinger@lemmy.worldtoSelfhosted@lemmy.world•ChatGPT fried my drive!? [Solved]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    25
    arrow-down
    38
    ·
    11 months ago

    Can you blame them?

    The manuals are written by experts for experts and in most cases entirely useless for complete beginners who likely won’t be able to even find the right manual page (or even the right manual to begin with).

    Tutoral pages are overwhelmingly AI vomit too, but AI vomit from last year’s AI, so even worse than asking AI right now.

    Asking for help online just gets you a “lol, RTFM, noob!”

    Look at this thread right now and count how many snarky bullshit answers are there that don’t even try to answer the question, how many answers like “I got no idea” are there and then how many actually helpful answers are here.

    Can you really blame anyone who turns to AI, because that garbage at least sounds like it tries to help you?





  • It’s a worthy and huge endeavor.

    I think the only somewhat sustainable way to get around the moderation problem is to get rid of storing a copy of everything.

    That way you don’t have incriminating data on your server and then you just mark every external community as “out of bounds of my moderation, there be dragons, go at your own risk” and call it a day.

    If a Lemmy/ActivityPub alternative was designed from the ground up a decent option would be to limit federation to a single-signon and private messages. In that case when you visit a remote community, the client directly goes to that remote community to fetch data from there.

    Basically like a set of separate forums with a federated login.

    That would solve the “everything copies everything” issue and the “everyone has to moderate everything” issue as well. If someone posts illegal crap on a remote instance, that data stays on that remote instance and you aren’t responsible for them. And the users can themselves decide what communities on what instances fit to what they want to look at.

    That would mean that if an instance goes down their communities do as well, but that’s (at least to me) less of an issue than the current state. It’s not like these zombie communities work fine right now. With the source instance being down, federation is gone and thus posting on these instances means there’s only a fraction of the audience left.


  • Yeah, with the current “everything replicates everything” model Lemmy is close to the workable limit of users.

    Currently, there are roughly 50k monthly active users on Lemmy, and the hosting cost is approaching unsustainability for hobby instances with a decent amount of users. Monetizing Lemmy is close to impossible with donations being the only real revenue stream, so there’s pretty much no business case for anything but a hobby instance.

    If for some reason even just 1% of Reddit users were to migrate to Lemmy (that would be ~10mio monthly active users) Lemmy would instantly crumble under that load no matter how many new instances would be added since every instance stores everything.

    Moderation would also all but collapse since each instance needs to moderate everything as well, due to legal reasons. (If someone posts something illegal on a remote instance and it gets replicated to your instance and you don’t delete it, you are legally liable for it since it’s stored on your server.)


  • The design choice to hard-bind an instance to a host name still baffles me. It’s an incredibly brittle choice. It makes it pretty much impossible to ever move an instance to another hostname.

    Sadly, the fediverse is full of amateurish design choices because it was designed by hobbyists who apparently don’t have anything but a very basic understanding of distributed systems.

    Also the concept of “Every instance needs to keep a full copy of everything” and “Every instance has to re-moderate everything to not be legally liable for illegal content” is really bad for scalability.




  • I’'d argue changing who can see your data from either a large group to a smaller one or one you do trust vs one you do not trust precisely is protecting your privacy.

    It’s always astounding to me that people put more trust in an intangible rando from the internet than into organizations governed by law. Like those people who don’t accept mainstream medicine but eat random supplements they imported from India by the kilogram.

    Also FWIW you can host your VPN, you do not have to rely on a commercial VPN provider.

    Sure you can. And where does that traffic go?

    If you e.g. host a VPN in your home network and you connect to it from your phone, and then you use this connection to access the internet, then your traffic will just be visible to your home network’s ISP instead of your phone’s ISP.