• 0 Posts
  • 59 Comments
Joined 7 months ago
cake
Cake day: April 19th, 2026

help-circle
  • Rather surveillance-capitalism’s raw input is data. It needs new data flows to survive. Stop the data and you stop surveillance-capitalism. Mobile-computers become increasingly sophisticated and that’s purely out of necessity: surveillance-capitalists need more data and you’re the free-labour that roams and surveils for them using their newly designed mobile-computers that have twenty lenses and microphones. Nothing can satiate their desire for more data, which means more profits. Slap a computer on your head and collect more! Get to work serf!





  • The cat has long been out of the bag. Only the cat is invisible (data) and the bag’s a computer. This invisible collection, sale and synthesis of data has become a central component of modern economies now. People playing Pokemon Go didn’t know (and the authors of the game-software probably didn’t know either) that they were collecting data for the use of training autonomous-suicide-drones. This is the economy now. This is surveillance-capitalism.

    You can’t lobby for regulation, removedation or prohibition. Capital has invested large sums and that investment is paying dividends. Capital is flowing into this sector and something capitalists refrain from writing is that labour is subjugated entirely by capital. Capitalism is a dictatorship. That means scientists, engineers, technologists, marketers and others now find their jobs being: how can we make ever more sophisticated computers, networks and ways to surveil. This surveillance is done to generate data. Then capital is allocated in the pursuit of synthesizing this data into saleable products. One of its results is the ‘AI’ that you can use from ChatGPT or whatever it’s called. A less known result is the AI being sold to nation-states that target and kill autonomously.

    There’s no going back. You and your child live under the dictatorship of capital. You live under capitalism. You are a commodity to be brought and sold by capitalists.

    Aside from overwhelming collective-action this can not be stopped. The organization that brought these things are largely ignorant and non-caring. The most you’ll get from them is usually a parroting of “we value your privacy and it’s protected under some law” (which doesn’t protect anything). They don’t care. To care would be to prohibit all new procurements–this is what the market is now selling; this is what’s cheapest. It does something beneficial for them so they brought it. The fact it came with a computer that surveils the children is besides the point. The data is invisible and the computer is small and hidden. Out of sight out of mind. The cat’s invisible. It never purrs or meows. It only demands two things: electricity and a connection. But that’s normal. Everything requires those.







  • I’m bemused by what I’ll write next as it’s something I would have totally disregarded–that’s to say I see a reflection of my thoughts in what you’ve written. Those thoughts have changed with time. What you want to do is propagandise. I think that’s a complete waste of energy. That enthusiasm would be better spent learning or writing libre-software that you want.


  • You can’t. Accept that statement. Acknowledge that you’re only in control of your body. You can influence others, but you cannot control them. Align yourself with your beliefs without forcing your beliefs onto others.

    I know users would like to interject, probably with something like “these aren’t beliefs; they’re objectively bad.” I would agree with that criticism. Beliefs are sometimes aligned with reality and other times they’re not. I believe proprietary-software is evil and I agree with a lot of things Richard Stallman has written.

    From the outside I know a lot of people don’t understand and I’m fine with that–I’m not in control of others nor do I want to be (that would be a tremendous burden). I do what I want to do, which is a reflection of my beliefs. When your body aligns with your desires (which stem from your beliefs) you’ll be most content.

    I don’t want a Google account. I think creating a Google account is actively causing harm. If someone suggest Facebook, Instagram, Whatsapp, et al as a way of communicating I refuse. If they inquire I’ll explain my reasoning if I perceive their curiosity to be genuine and offer an alternative solution, but the thing I want to impress upon you here is that I’m doing what I want to do.

    People have written and said particulars to me that I know others see my behaviour as a type of “self-restraint” or to phrase it another way: of forgoing convenience in favour of something. They perceive the action of adhering to libre-software as a burden. It’s not. It’s what I want to do. It’s what I like to do. (It’s what excites and brings me pleasure.)

    I’d probably like it if other people also shared my preferences and I know some do. I also know some don’t. I think they should, but I don’t want to shoulder that burden. It’s an impossible load. I can’t force people to do what I think is the correct thing to do. It is impossible. It’s also probably wrong–most definitely wrong.

    Do what you want to do and accept that others are doing what they want to do. If there’s conflict try to resolve it. If it can not be resolved to the satisfaction of both parties part ways amicably.

    If you think you can coerce someone with enough persistence–and if you’re using this thread to gain motivation to continue–you’re in the wrong. Do not do it.




  • I apologize. The reply you responded to was entirely satirical. It was written in frustration. From my point of view passkeys are the way to do authentication. More specifically public-key cryptography. It has a lot of desirable qualities. Governments and ‘tech platforms’ should have been using it from the start–we’ve had the software to do this since the 1980s and it was libre-software by the 1990s.

    Any criticism of passkeys (as brought up in this thread) are more so applicable to the private-dictatorships that are Microsoft, Apple and Google. The contrary behavior of continuing to use these private-dictatorships whilst decrying passkeys is tantamount to hypocrisy? stupidity? To give a tiny bit of context: the quality of attestation in passkeys are also applicable to SSL-certificates, yet no one is decrying SSL-certificates. It’s also applicable to every GNU/Linux distribution and libre-software at large.

    That’s to say the criticism is written from a place of ignorance. “Privacy” forums on the internet are not interested in reality. Their users are full of users with static behaviors. More often than not any questions asked in these places amount to “how can I continue doing what I was doing before? Big-corp has introduced a change I don’t like. I want to do the exact same thing on big-corp that was previously permissible.” When the factual observation is stated: “big-corp is a corporation designed for surveillance-capitalism therefore if you desire liberty and privacy whilst computing you cannot use such a corporation in any manner” it’s met with unfounded hostility, hypocrisy and lies. Any use of such software is contrary to your stated desire: digital-privacy. Even when responses illustrate how you could achieve what the OP wanted, but with libre-software and privacy-preserving-software you’re often met with: “no. I want to use Google/Microsoft/et al.” Users are lazy idiots.

    Technical and correct responses are ignored whilst a flood of ignorant, emotional or status-quo enforcing responses are brought to magnified attention. I’ve abandoned restraint and started to shitpost as every one else appears to be doing.

    I suppose this is all a criticism of ‘social-media’ and how it’s a waste of everyone’s time.


  • Google does this: “wow best thing ever look at the cranks getting upset. No privacy in public places. Thanks Google.”

    Amazon does this: “wow worst thing ever–they’re not even letting me look at the data.”

    Daily reminder: you’re sharing a video hosted on YouTube. Inconsistency and lack of logic will get us to privacy one day. Keep at it gang! Chins up! Port paddle in reverse! Starboard paddle straight–we’ll get there in no time! Such enthusiasm!


  • dropdrip@lemmy.mltoPrivacy@lemmy.ml•Passkeys are a trap. Do not use them
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    1 month ago

    No, I’m not assuming people are using a Google wallet.

    Most businesses only release an android package via Google’s PlayStore. (“Download our app via PlayStore.”)There’s no reason a bank couldn’t host their .apks on their website (if you’re unfamiliar with the .apk extension imagine it’s a .exe: you click on it and a program runs; an .apk is to Android what an .exe is to Windows). To download packages from Google’s PlayStore requires a Google account. Google demands a few things from these two parties: publishers need to pay Google a fee to have their .apk hosted by Google and users need to run Google’s spyware in order to access those .apks hosted by Google.

    It’s often stated that if you want digital-freedom/privacy use GrapheneOS (if you have a compatible Android-device) or use a linux mobile-phone. To which most users respond: but my bank app doesn’t work on those platforms, therefore I won’t use either GrapheneOS or a linux-phone.

    The bank app won’t work, because Google’s spyware is not included in GrapheneOS (a point of GrapheneOS is to avoid such spyware). Because GrapheneOS (or linux) doesn’t include Google’s spyware Google will do its best to block such devices from accessing Google’s PlayStore. Such computers are violating Google’s demands: if you want access to the PlayStore you have to run Google’s spyware.

    Even if you were to get the appropriate .apk by avoiding Google directly (perhaps a friend who got it from Google then passed it to you) the bank’s .apk would fail to run on a device free of Google’s spyware, because you’re not capitulating to Google’s demand: you didn’t get it from Google’s PlayStore and the ‘app’ knows that by the lack of Google spyware. (Google’s spyware and the bank ‘app’ talk to each other. If the app can’t talk to Google’s spyware it will halt.)

    Therefore if a bank only has an ‘app’ to interact with that bank is saying: you have to download it via Google’s PlayStore–which necessitates a Google account and running Google’s spyware. Therefore if you want to use banking ‘apps’ you need to enable Google’s monopolistic, spyware practices (you have to enable the corporations to practice surveillance-capitalism). Google defends this practice often with security-theater (“Google says it must be done this way for security.”) when in reality it’s about entrenching a market monopoly.

    This is absolutely removed and I do deride users who say they want computing-liberty and -privacy, because there are banks who still have usable websites. You don’t have to bank via an app. If you do bank via an app you do so with full acknowledgment that: a) you’re rewarding anti-competitive behavior; b) you’re entrenching Google’s monopoly over Android; c) you don’t actually want computing-liberty or -privacy.

    It’s piss easy to change banks. It’s impossible to stop Google. If you want privacy you have to ditch Google, which means banking with a bank that allows you to bank via a desktop-computer (via a website) or in-person through bank-branches. If the only way to bank with your chosen bank is via an app that then means the only way to bank with your chosen bank is by enshrining Google’s monopoly into your life.

    Passkeys are a completely separate thing. They’re an increase in security for all users. Users are frustrated by ‘big tech’s’ increasingly monopolistic practices and instead of doing anything practical (like not running those particular pieces of software) they’ve latched on to decrying passkeys, which the majority of the commentators are actually clueless about. They’re just seeing those ‘big tech’ companies forcing yet another change onto them. They’re lashing out against their lack of power. They’re lashing out against their subjugation by ‘big tech’. That they’re being forced to use “passkeys” when they don’t even know what a passkey is.

    Passkeys are an open standard. They’re not entrenching anyone’s monopoly. Increased security is desirable by all parties (corporations, governments and individuals). Passkeys enable that. You’re not locked into Google’s Android, or Microsoft or Apple. People are under the assumption they are however.

    I could host my own website using passkeys as the method for authentication. No big-corp involved. Offline. Spooky. Big-passkey is coming for you.

    That probably left you with more questions than answers…


  • It’s something you pass around–like a word, but a key instead. If you’re familiar with passwords–instead of a word–imagine a key: a passkey. That’s what passkeys are. The issue with passkeys is–as you pass them around they begin to open more and more stuff; everyone is opening stuff with your key as it’s passed. So they need to be sanitized every now and then. Deposit them into a furnace and buy a new passkey. Every two to three days. If you have more questions please feel free to ask!



  • This is already the reality without passkeys. The correct response is to bank with a bank that isn’t enabling Google’s monopoly. Pretend passkeys don’t exist–nothing’s changed. You still can’t use your bank’s app without a Google Account if your bank is an enabler of Google’s monopoly. So… again, myopic dimwits are getting angry at something, but don’t know what. They’ve latched onto passkeys though. Amusing.