apotheotic (she/her)

Too cute to be cis 🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍🌈

Display picture by the wonderful Cynvii on bluesky and twitch

  • 0 Posts
  • 30 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 11th, 2023

help-circle
  • Crucially, we are forcing them to spend resources to remove the noise. And additionally, they can never be 100% confident on what is noise and what is real traffic, so they have to make a broad judgement between definitely removing all the noise but perhaps losing real data, or definitely keeping all the real data, but perhaps keeping noise.



  • As the author alludes to, the majority of this traffic will be easily discarded. It’s the 1-2% that they can’t be totally sure about which will cause them to either keep a bit of bogus data about you, or accidentally discard a bit of real data about you

    To take an analogy from image processing

    Say you have a perfect, crisp image of yourself. That’s analogous to (company) having a totally pristine dataset about your activities.

    Now, say, you introduce some uniform random noise to the image (this is the base level functionality of the Fauxx app without any of the other layers on).

    Image denoising algorithms are pretty darn good at getting a bunch of it out, but you have to decide on how aggressively you want to denoise. Denoise too little, and some noise remains but you can be fairly sure you’re not also losing some of the original image. Denoise too much, and you can be more sure that you’ve removed all the noise, but you risk losing data in the actual image.

    So, this app on its own isn’t going to take the average Joe’s public footprint and make them disappear behind a cloud of random bullshit, its effect would probably be more akin to a pane of very lightly frosted glass, once (company) is done discarding the obvious noise.

    As part of your overall privacy approach I think its valuable, and once its running in the background you’ll basically not notice it’s there. But nobody should be considering this as a magic bullet privacy solution.

    Re: them being able to detect and remove noise based on your existing data they already have by training on it - they totally could, and depending how much data they already have, they might have excellent results in doing so. However, performing that process is costly on resources and time (not for one user, but generally). It is likely more efficient for them to take rather dumb approaches to removing noise that are not as effective but cost less and run faster.

















  • So like, its not necessarily about offense. Some folks who have suffered abuse and aggression because of their minority status have visceral, trauma responses to certain things. When I hear the t-slur used, for example, it invokes a deep anxiety and panic. That doesn’t mean that I think that anyone who says it is a transphobe (like the car guy in your example might be talking about his transmission or some silly thing like that) and I’m not going to rage and scream at him. But I’m not weird or wrong for asking him not to say it because it triggers me. This isn’t a discussion about how we should cancel people for using words, its a discussion about how we can accommodate our fellow people.

    The OP shows some folks making a change that is so minor we shouldn’t even be talking about it, so that they can be just a touch more likely not to affect someone negatively. Even if its performative, who cares, they did it and it affects nobody negatively.

    More concerning, I think, is the people jumping in this thread acting like this is woke cancel culture gone wild and we can’t use normal words anymore.


  • I have realised, upon reflection, what I take issue with with your argument.

    It places the onus on the intention, as opposed to the result.

    If the result of me doing something particularly mundane, that I could do another way with zero extra effort, is that some people are offended or othered or hurt, then it seems blatantly obvious to me that the action to take is to change what I’m doing. Theres nuance in the wider discussion but you can’t judge intentions, since nobody can know what someone else’s intentions are. You can judge actions and outcomes.

    The action in this case is mundane, and I don’t place any blame or hate toward the people who took the action (made the Tycoon joke). The outcome is potentially negative, and I would argue demonstrably negative since people felt compelled to comment about it. It still doesn’t mean that the folks who wrote the joke are massive racists or fascists or whatever, but the outcome related to their action is negative. Hence they chose to change the action to change the outcome.

    Seems pretty cut and dry that this was a wholly positive thing, no?