• 1 Post
  • 33 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: August 8th, 2023

help-circle


  • So you basically ARE calling me a narcissist by proxy, or a defender of narcissists at best.

    I can’t speak to your interpretation but it was not my intention to do so.

    For me to be calling you a narcissist i’d need to claim you were saying those things to defend yourself, which you clearly weren’t.

    The company isn’t saying that about themselves either.

    Well, no more Mullvad for me. Thanks for pointing that out. There are several good alternatives.

    This was also not my intention, but i can’t say i’m upset at this outcome.

    I’ll keep it brief. I do find the controversies comparable, for the reasons previously stated…etc

    All reasonable takes and i wasn’t trying to imply you were trying to sway me, i was just stating my opinions and boundaries were different from yours in this case.

    I don’t consider the shenanigans equal on both sides, but we can agree to disagree on this.

    Worth noting that the CEO was the CEO of FIREFOX at the time of the LGBT controversy. He was forced out due to the backlash, so good on Mozilla …etc

    Fully agreed, in this case i fall on the mozilla side because, as i said, to me it’s the least worst.

    The only reason I point out of something is not “as bad” is because I don’t believe it is possible to stay completely away from supporting anyone controversial…etc

    Also agreed, there is no ethical consumerism so you do what you can live with.


  • I reread the narcissist thing and I’m really not sure what you mean then. Are you calling the Brave CEO a narcissist?

    I was referring to a theoretical corporate defence version of the narcissists prayer and was again bitten by my ridiculous expectation that meme/reference knowledge is universal

    Specifically your defence of brave sounded to me like this slightly altered version of that prayer

    That didn’t happen.
    And if it did, it wasn’t that bad.
    And if it was, that’s not a big deal.
    And if it is, that’s not their fault.
    And if it was, they didn’t mean it.

    I wasn’t trying to imply you are they were narcissists, only that your reply sounded a lot like that prayer.


    I wasn’t sure if you were referring to either or both, so I responded to both versions of what you could mean by that. Based in your last comment I have a feeling I didn’t hear something recent about them, as far as I know everyone still likes them.

    ah, again, with my assumptions:

    TL;DR; A mullvad founder donated a large amount of money to what is largely considered to be a right wing political party

    Here’s a small selection links, should be easy to search once you know what to look for:

    Note, there is obviously bias and opinions here, have a look in to the actual details yourself for a full picture.


    I do see a pattern, which is why I said I don’t fully trust them …etc

    I agree with all of that up to this part:

    Brave I trust a little less, but I see them in a similar way: often trying to find a crackpot method to make money off their product so they can stick around.

    If their crackpot experiments are at the expense of the things i care about i’m out, but that’s a personal opinion, not a universal viewpoint.


    I can’t say I’m a fan of their CEO. Then again, I can’t say I particularly like any CEO of any company,…etc

    Again, all reasonable takes up to the end part:

    I’m forced to pay Microsoft for licenses and support at work, and that bothers my conscience more than using a free browser by a guy who didn’t support gay marriage in 2014 before it went through federally, like just about everyone I grew up with, most of whom have since gotten over themselves. Not saying it’s OK or right, just noting that was at least half of Americans back then.

    “He’s not as bad as musk and gates, plus everyone of that generation was like that” sounds a lot like an excuse, even if you specifically state that it isn’t.


    I agree with your assessment that Firefox used to be the default good option and get steadily worse every day. …etc

    Agreed


    Does this make Firefox a stupid option that I’d criticize people for using? No. It is still one of the best options we ha…etc

    Again, agreed, until the end.

    “I’m gonna do it anyway” VS “Hey guys what about this?” “WTAF were you thinking Brave?” “Oh, sorry…”

    That’s entirely glossing over the nature of the sketchy shit being pulled.

    As we said mozilla are just stacking those shitty decisions like they were bricks of gold.

    but they haven’t done anything even remotely a sketchy as :

    • Referral injection/affiliate jacking
    • Replacing ads with their own
    • This

    Presenting it like they are doing comparable things is disingenuous at best.


  • Senal@programming.devtoPrivacy@lemmy.ml•Firefox has become a bloatware. Seriously...
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    4 months ago

    edit: well shit, i just realised i used a meme/reference that might have been mistaken for me specifically implying an economic reason not to use mullvad.

    That’s my bad for assuming universal meme knowledge.

    <X>, in this economy? was predominantly used to reference economic reasons to not doing something, it has broadened in scope to encompass the idea that the proceeding statement is nonsensical in general (not just for economic reasons)

    So “mullvad, in this economy ?” roughly translates to “mullvad is a questionable choice in this current (specific or general) context”


    What a strange comment. Can’t say I’ve ever been called a narcissist for recommending privacy browsers before.

    No one was calling you a narcissist, read it again.

    Mullvad is pretty much the most trusted VPN provider. If you don’t want to pay for a VPN, don’t. I explicitly mentioned it is still a good privacy by default Firefox based browser without the bloat of Firefox.

    And my comment had nothing to do with its technical competence (nor it’s economic impact, see note at the top)

    Have you really not seen any stories related to mullvad recently?

    Sure, let’s go through your list, why not.

    Not my list, a list.

    And all of those explanations are the handwaving I mentioned.

    Your take on them all seems reasonable if not exactly the same as mine.

    In aggregate though they indicate a potential pattern.

    My response was specifically to your implication that because their many shenanigans were in the past and nothing was a current problem that we should only judge them on their current technical competence.

    I also noticed you didn’t mention the current CEO and why someone might have an issue with them.

    I just think it’s really weird that Brave gets so much hate when it isn’t warranted when compared to what other browsers do.

    Then you probably aren’t hearing all of what people are actually complaining about.

    hint : they aren’t usually complaining about the technical competence.

    Also other browsers get plenty of shit, a lot of it justifiable.

    Ungoogled Chromium, for example…etc

    All valid, and I agree.

    I could list some you haven’t mentioned as well.

    I personally use a variant of Firefox that has a whole bunch of questionable shit turned off or removed.

    Despite almost all of their recent moves having been to announce some bullshit that actively makes them a worse option for me they are still currently , barely, the least worst option (for my preferences)

    And only then it’s mostly because of the variants.

    What I was getting at is that playing down the continuous bullshit from these companies weakens your arguments.

    It also genuinely seems you don’t see why the non-technical aspects of these companies might be a point of contention for some people.





  • TL;DR;

    Sounds like a bunch of organisational issues using licensing as a scapegoat.

    Again, not giving an opinion on FOSS licencing pro’s and cons, just on the implementation of licensing in general.


    My issue with viral licensing is that it means you got to rewrite the code or use another product.

    Or…comply with the licence.

    but yes, that’s entirely the intention of a licence.

    You can use this thing as long as you adhere to the rules set forth, if you don’t want to then feel free to create your own or find something with a licence more to your liking.

    They aren’t forcing this on you, using these products is optional.

    Also software bom is a hassle.

    Absolutely.

    However, that feels more like a procurement/evaluation issue.

    e.g : “is bringing in this open source, viral GPL audio processing library worth the trade-off of dealing with the compliance vs paying money for a similar commercial product (or building our own)”

    Some advanced manufacturing techniques rely on advanced software. So does infrastructure which is often only secured by obscurity. Also all software is filled with vulnerabilities which can get easier to exploit if you have access to the source code.

    That sounds again like a person or persons have royally fucked up their evaluation/procurement duties when selecting the components to use in the building of the product a, quality/security/systems design issue rather than a licensing one.

    if complying with an open source license causes a product to become a danger to the public, many people, at many stages, have utterly failed to do their job.

    Also,i’m sure you know this, but security through obscurity is a poor systems design choice in almost all scenarios.

    As you say though, it does happen in the real world.

    In those cases someone needs to wear the grown up hat and evaluate the options available, such as removing or replacing the component that requires opening up your source code, or evaluating the trade off of how severe a risk opening up the source code is vs the costs involved in replacing it, or even the potential legal liability of just ignoring the licence.

    If you can’t afford any options then your product isn’t viable ( in an “everybody follows the rules” kind of scenario, at least).


  • Im not expressing an opinion on the viral nature of the licence itself, nor the pros and cons of FOSS, nor am I a FOSS evangelist of any kind.

    But you understand it’s optional right? if you don’t like it, don’t use it.

    This isn’t some gotcha, you can literally decide not to use the thing under the licence you don’t like. That will solve 100% of the problems you are describing (though it sounds like it’d introduce new, non-licence based problems in whatever example you are thinking of)

    Well… I say that, but im actually not sure what you mean by “dangerous to the public”, if you could go in to a bit more detail about what you mean there, I’d appreciate it









  • I shouldn’t have anything to hide, but I’m part of a group the current fascist leadership in government want’s to eradicate, so hide I shall.

    I agree and i think a lot of people who espouse “nothing to hide” as an approach haven’t actually thought it all the way through.

    Then there’s the fascists, dictators, oligarchs and other all around shitbags who just want the control.

    That said, I also feel like people acting like the remote server they are connected to is tracking what you do on it as some kind of surprise is so stupid. “Facebook is keeping track of the pictures I uploaded to it!!!” There’s a lot of stuff to complain about Facebook, google, or whoever, but them tracking stuff you send to them willingly isn’t one of them.

    This always surprises me, i originally thought it was because people didn’t understand how these things work or how capitalist companies work.

    More and more it seems like people don’t care until it affects them, which is somewhat understandable, it takes effort to care about this stuff and a lot of people will never be directly affected by the consequences.

    What i do still think is that the general population has no idea the extent of what can be done with all of the information they are volunteering.

    That’s very slowly changing but the usages of the data are also increasing at a much more rapid pace than before.


  • Oh yeah, the whole article could be reductively summed up as

    “DeepSeek and all the other LLM services are almost as bad as each other, but we think deepseek is worse…because the Chinese government are known for doing bad things”.

    The title is factual, if a little clickbaity.

    Obviously keystrokes you submit to a website are submitted to the website.

    This though, it’s not technically accurate, a lot of forms and input are done client side and then the resulting information is parceled up and sent to the server.

    The actual keystroke data isn’t normally sent.

    Though this article doesn’t go in to what kind of keystroke data is sent, if it was something more than just which keys in which order then that’s perhaps an indicator that it’s actively being collected for a reason, rather than just incidentally.

    If you want to get really paranoid about such things it’s known that you can you can do interesting things with actual keystroke data.

    Also, afaict none of the the non-chinese services have specified that they don’t do this.