I think one of the problems is there isn’t really any reliable way to know the date a website was made on, so you can’t really filter on that. Its the search engines that keep that information in their indexes, so if you built a new database, it wouldn’t have access to it.
I don’t see why it wouldn’t get spammed by SEO spammed websites and AI spammed websites. Maybe your wikipedia style moderation might help, but it does sound like a lot of work for people when AI can spam new websites faster than any human can review them.
I do think we really do need to rethink the internet though, because its starting to feel pretty useless.


I use a different one for every signup and have been doing it that way for decades. To make it easier to remember, I usually add the website name in the email like ‘google@mydomain.ca’. That way if I start getting spam from that address I know who to blame. It also makes it easy to send all that incoming spam directly to the garbage.